This also completely excludes all Treehouse games (something that goes against the new sales strategy) unless they hold a new contest (or unless the new PDF project counts as "published").
Why not make "Award-Winning" and "Published" game listing pages and make this page a master index? (I think there should be an Award-Winning category and maybe a small notation graphic (like a merit badge) that those games can include on their pages is a good idea no matter what happens with this page.)
Alternatively, if you still feel a velvet rope is needed, you could have a committee or selection process that would let games "graduate" up to the page so that newer games would have some chance of inclusion.
Not to sound like an ego-bearing jerk, but I think Zamboni Wars is polished enough to warrant inclusion. It can play with Treehouse and Martian Coasters (making it a good game for post-convention shoppers), has rules in English and Spanish, has (IMHO) well-illustrated rules with full-color photographs, and has been well received by folks on the list and by playtesters. I'd gladly submit it for publication and/or a design contest if either were a current option, but I think that's a pretty high bar.
Now that you can't get single-color stashes, it does more harm than good to send people to a page with games that require them. I think it would best serve the game (and Looney Labs) to have a more inclusive page that includes as many Treehouse games that can fit.
On 4/13/07, David Artman <david@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
OK, I have pondered this some, and I have some strong words regarding
the "Choosing Games" wiki page's current conceptual make-up.
* Given: Publishing a pyramid game has so far been controlled through
Looney Labs' ability and willingness to print.
* Given: The vast majority of Icehouse games have been created after
Hypothermia went out of print.
* Given: I haven't heard of or seen an Icehouse Game Design contest
since I've been an owner of pyramids.
* Given: Many Icehouse games can't translate to a computer format--and
I'd argue many more SHOULDN'T (whatever happened to getting together