On Monday, March 24, 2008, at 10:07AM, "Jorge Arroyo" <trozo@xxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote: >Another possibility is to ask non-designers to provide feedback and to >require designers to provide feedback. This way if you want to participate >with your game, you know you have to provide feedback for all the entries so >that your entry is valid. This seems reasonable if we expect voting turnout >not to increase anytime soon. At least this way we know we won't decrease it >while we also know all the games will get some amount of feedback for sure. This suggestion is excellent. Putting additional burden on layman judges is definitely a BAD IDEA. We don't need any more reason to lower turnout of judging. Putting this burden on entrants, is a great idea, ensuring that all entrants will have some real feedback.