On Tue, Mar 25, 2008 at 6:20 AM, Jorge Arroyo <trozo@xxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote: > Hi, let's hear more opinions about the latest suggestion: To require contest > entrants to submit a short paragraph of feedback for all the other entries > to the contest in order for their own entry to be valid (about 3-5 lines of > text), and to explicitly encourage judges to do the same (although they > won't be forced to do it). > > I think this may work very well because it won't reduce the number of judges > and it will increase the useful feedback that all designers need. In fact I > really like it because I see it as a useful trade of feedback between all > participants. So, you want to enter your game in the contest and get > feedback? Ok. Then you have to provide feedback for all the entries too. It > seems really fair. > > More thoughts, please? Sounds like a valid suggestion to me, although what if I don't play one of the entries: should I still have to provide some feedback on it? Since I didn't play game "x" does that kick my game out of the contest? -Jason