That has kind of been my issue. The kids absolutely hate being villagers so roles like the Best Friends (my name for lovers since there are only 2 girls in my class of 12 and the matchmaker leads to too much giggling if they choose two guys) work well because the kid feels like they got something special rather than a vanilla villager.
The Little Girl role I can imagine being too difficult to police and it also just made me think that it would kind of encourage practicing the ability to cheat. I probably won't use it any.
I looked on the Wikipedia entry and didn't see any entry for Alchemist/Watchmen so I'm curious what that role does. Is it the same as the Witch?
At the rate this is going, every single villager will be a special character.
That's not an entirely bad idea, from some perspectives.
- |) () /\/
Ora, lege, lege, lege, relege, labora et invenies.